Dorico vs. Sibelius for film and orchestral scoring
A documentation-verified way to choose between Dorico and Sibelius when you need to write an orchestral score, prepare parts, and work to picture.
Written by Software for Music Editorial Team · Music software research and fact-checking
Reviewed by Software for Music Editorial Team
| Feature | DoricoSteinberg | SibeliusAvid |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing Model | Dorico 6 family: SE 6 free; Elements 6 $99.99; Pro 6 $579.99 (full versions). Currency: USD · free-tier-and-paid | Sibelius Artist $99/year; Sibelius Ultimate $199/year (1-year paid upfront); Ultimate Perpetual Bundle $899. Sibelius First is free. Monthly billing is also offered (current monthly prices: https://www.avid.com/sibelius). Currency: USD, excluding VAT and taxes · free-tier, subscription and perpetual |
| OS Support | Windows 10 64-bit (version 1809) and Windows 11; macOS 12, 13, 14, 15, 26 (Intel and Apple silicon). Dorico for iPad is a separate free app | Sibelius 2026.9: Windows 10 or 11 for Artist and First, Windows 11 for Ultimate; macOS 14, 15, 26, 27 for Artist and Ultimate. Avid also lists mobile apps |
| Ensemble limit | SE 6: up to 8 players. Elements 6 and Pro 6: unlimited players | First: create and edit up to 8 staves (larger scores open read-only). Artist: up to 24 staves per score. Ultimate: unlimited staves |
| Video / timecode | Video, markers and timecodes are documented in the Dorico SE 6.2, Elements 6.2 and Pro 6.2 manuals | Avid lists "Video sync & timecode support" on the Ultimate plans, not on the Artist plan |
| Included sounds | Pro: 2000+ sounds (13 GB), including HALion Symphonic Orchestra. Elements: 1500 sounds (8 GB). SE: 1500 sounds (2 GB) | Avid describes a 35 GB Sibelius Ultimate sound library. Avid's system requirements list 36 GB for Sibelius Sounds with Ultimate and 10 GB with Artist |
| Format | Third-party VST support in SE, Elements and Pro (not Dorico for iPad) | Third-party VST3 and AU virtual instruments |
| NotePerformer 5 | Supported from Dorico 3.5 | Supported from Sibelius 7.1.3 |
| Best For |
|
|
| Links |
Prices use each product's cited edition, price basis, and stated currency from the shared catalog. Purchase, subscription, free tier, and time-limited trial terms are kept distinct; amounts are not converted or presented as a like-for-like cost.
Quick decision
Choose Dorico when you want a player-based score model, a free SE edition to learn on, and a one-time full-version price for Elements or Pro. Choose Sibelius when you already think in its single master score with dynamic parts, or when a subscription with an optional perpetual bundle suits how you buy software.
For film and orchestral work, the edition matters more than the brand. Dorico SE 6 stops at eight players and Sibelius Artist stops at 24 staves, so a full orchestra points to Dorico Elements or Pro on one side and Sibelius Ultimate on the other. If you work to picture, Avid lists video sync and timecode support on Sibelius Ultimate only. Steinberg's manuals document video, markers and timecodes in all three desktop Dorico editions, including the free SE.
This article doesn't repeat prices beyond the table. Read the edition, currency and price basis together, and don't compare a yearly subscription with a one-time purchase as if they were the same kind of number.
What is actually being compared
Dorico 6 is a family of three desktop editions. SE is a free download for up to eight players, Elements is aimed at students and home users, and Pro adds Steinberg's professional engraving tools, more sounds and deeper customisation. Projects made in Dorico SE are compatible with the other Dorico editions, so starting free doesn't trap the score.
Sibelius is sold mainly as a subscription. Artist covers up to 24 staves per score with limited symbols, lines and text styles. Ultimate removes the staff limit and adds the complete engraving feature set, video sync and timecode support. The Ultimate Perpetual Bundle adds PhotoScore Ultimate and AudioScore Ultimate to a lifetime licence. Sibelius First is Avid's free version. Since Sibelius 2025.7 it can create and edit scores of up to 8 staves, and it opens larger scores read-only for playback and printing. A lapsed Sibelius subscription reverts to Sibelius First, so your files stay readable.
Both programs import and export MusicXML and MIDI, so you can move a score between them. Treat that move as an interchange rather than a perfect conversion: check layout, playback techniques and part formatting after any import.
Orchestral scoring: what to test
Start with ensemble size. A string orchestra with divisi, doubled winds, percussion and a harp can exceed Dorico SE's eight players or Sibelius Artist's 24 staves sooner than you expect. Count players and staves before you choose an edition.
Next, test the part-preparation tasks your scores actually need. Steinberg's edition table lists condensing, cues, divisi for divided string sections, ossia staves and custom page layout as Dorico Pro features. Elements and SE don't have them. Avid highlights Dynamic Parts, which sync every edit between score and parts, plus Auto-orchestration, Magnetic Layout and an Inspector for fine control. Dorico Pro and Dorico Elements both list Explode and Reduce.
Use one representative passage in both programs: transposing instruments, a divisi string passage, a cue, a percussion staff, tuplets and a page turn. These are decision criteria, not a claim that either program engraves every score correctly without editing.
Film scoring: working to picture
For picture work, check four things in the exact edition you plan to buy: whether you can attach a video, which frame rates it supports, how it handles timecode, and how you get the audio and score back out.
Dorico's help documents attaching a video to each flow in Setup mode in Dorico SE 6.2, Elements 6.2 and Pro 6.2, with a Video Properties dialog for frame rate, flow attachment position, video start offset and timecode start. The SE manual says video plays back in sync with the music in a separate Video window, and lists MOV, MP4 and AVI support, common frame rates from 23.976 to 30 fps, and resolutions up to 8K. Variable-frame-rate video isn't supported. Dorico Elements 6.2 documents frame rates from 23.976 to 60 fps, and Dorico Pro's help documents drop-frame and non-drop-frame timecodes per flow. In practice, SE's eight-player limit is a bigger constraint on picture work than its video tools.
On the Sibelius side, Avid's current plan cards list "Video sync & timecode support" for Ultimate and the Ultimate Perpetual Bundle, but not for Artist. If you score to picture in Sibelius, plan on Ultimate.
Notation programs are not DAWs. For a final mix, stems, or a session that has to match an editor's cut, you'll usually hand MIDI or audio to a DAW. Our Cubase vs. REAPER comparison covers that side.
Playback and NotePerformer 5
Each program ships its own sound set. Steinberg lists 2000+ sounds (13 GB) in Dorico Pro, including HALion Symphonic Orchestra, and 1500 sounds in Elements (8 GB) and SE (2 GB). Avid describes a 35 GB Sibelius Ultimate sound library and lists 10 GB for Sibelius Sounds with Artist. Both programs also host third-party virtual instruments: Steinberg lists third-party VST support in SE, Elements and Pro, and Avid lists VST3 and AU instruments.
NotePerformer 5 is the playback engine many composers add to either program. Wallander Instruments lists support from Sibelius 7.1.3 and Dorico 3.5. It reads the score and adds phrasing automatically, and its own site notes that it adds a one-second delay to playback. For picture work in Sibelius, NotePerformer's support guide recommends offsetting the video by one second to compensate. Our NotePerformer 5 setup guide walks through installing it in both programs.
Recommendations by user
For a student or composer learning on a chamber-sized score, start with Dorico SE 6 or Sibelius First. Both are free, and both stop at eight (players in Dorico, staves in Sibelius). Dorico SE can also attach a video, which makes it a no-cost way to practise a short cue to picture. Move to Elements or Pro when the ensemble grows, after checking Steinberg's edition table.
For a film or media composer who needs video, timecode and a full orchestra in the notation program, compare Dorico Pro 6 with Sibelius Ultimate. Both are documented for picture work. The decision usually comes down to how each one handles your template, parts and house style on a real cue.
For a composer who already has years of Sibelius scores and house styles, Sibelius Ultimate keeps that workflow. Use MusicXML to trial Dorico on a copy before deciding to move.
For a composer whose main goal is better playback inside notation, treat NotePerformer 5 as a separate decision. It works in both programs, so it shouldn't decide Dorico vs. Sibelius by itself.
Who this comparison is for
This comparison is for composers, orchestrators and media composers choosing between the two main professional notation programs for orchestral work, especially when the decision turns on ensemble limits, video and timecode, or the difference between buying once and subscribing.
Who this comparison isn't for
This is not a hands-on engraving, playback-quality or CPU test, and it doesn't rank one program as the best. If you need a free notation program for a full orchestra, or you work on Linux, read the Dorico vs. MuseScore Studio comparison instead.
Dorico vs. Sibelius FAQ
These answers summarize the documented edition limits and decision points in this comparison.
Which edition do I need for a full orchestra?
In Dorico, use Elements 6 or Pro 6, because SE 6 is limited to eight players. In Sibelius, use Ultimate, because First is limited to 8 staves and Artist to 24 staves per score.
Which one supports video and timecode?
Steinberg's manuals document video, markers and timecodes in Dorico SE, Elements and Pro. Avid lists video sync and timecode support on Sibelius Ultimate, not on Sibelius Artist.
Is Dorico or Sibelius a one-time purchase?
Steinberg sells Dorico Elements 6 and Pro 6 as full versions at a listed price, and SE 6 is free. Sibelius Artist and Ultimate are subscriptions, Avid also sells a Sibelius Ultimate Perpetual Bundle, and Sibelius First is free.
Does NotePerformer 5 work in both?
Yes. Wallander Instruments lists NotePerformer 5 support from Sibelius 7.1.3 and from Dorico 3.5. It's sold separately from both programs.
Can I move a score from Sibelius to Dorico?
Both programs import and export MusicXML and MIDI. Expect to check layout, playback and parts after the import, because an interchange file doesn't carry everything.
Does this comparison test engraving or playback quality?
No. It's a documentation-verified comparison, not a hands-on benchmark or listening test.
Limitations and evidence
Edition limits, operating-system support and prices change with new releases. Avid's Windows requirement for Sibelius Ultimate 2026.9 lists Windows 11 only, while Artist and First still list Windows 10 and 11. Check the current requirements before you buy. Avid also shows a time-limited promotion on its pricing page, so read the list price and the renewal terms together.
This is a documentation-verified comparison, not a hands-on review. We didn't run either program for this article. It makes no claim about rendering quality, engraving speed or CPU use. The official pages below are the authority for any newer release.